Menu

Our Thanksgiving Menu is Here!

We are so excited to share another holiday with you!  We’re an all-from-scratch bakery, and that means we need a bit more time to make sure your holiday orders are just perfect in every way.  Please place all Thanksgiving orders by Saturday, November 22nd at 5PM so we can serve you best.  We can’t wait to create some wonderful desserts for you and your family!

Cookies & Bars

  • Classic Favorites $1.50ea, $17/dozen
    • Crispy-Chewy Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter (Gluten Free!), Snickerdoodles
  • Cookies With a Twist $1.65ea, $19/dozen
    • Mitten Made Cookies, Pumpkin Oatmeal Chip, Mustard Molasses
  • Decorated Sugar Cookies $2.25ea, $27/dozen
    • Decorated, Thanksgiving-themed, and uber-adorable!
  • Gingerbread Cookies $1.75 ea, $21/dozen
    • Fallish, spicy, and amazingly delicious
  • French Madeleines  $15/dozen
    • Classic Vanilla Honey, Lavender, Cinnamon Spice
  • Sandwich Cookies $21/dozen for regular, $41/dozen for jumbos
    • Carrot Cake Cookies
      • Two irresistible Carrot Cake Cookies sandwiched with Cream Cheese filling (not available in jumbos-sorry!)
    • Peanutter Butters
      • Our take on the classic Nutter Butter–two Peanut Butter Cookies with Peanut Butter filling
    • Pumpkin Nutella
      • Our Pumpkin Oatmeal Chip Cookies filled with Nutella Buttercream
    • Chocolate Chip Bomber
      • Chocolate Chip Cookies sandwiched with Vanilla Buttercream
    • Mitten Made Sammie
      • Our Signature cookie packed with Potato Chips, Pretzels, Coffee, Chocolate, & Butterscotch; stuffed with Espresso Buttercream
    • Sugary Sweet Snickerdoodle
      • Our Cinnamon Snickerdoodles filled with our favorite Confetti Buttercream
    • Orange Spice Molasses
      • Sweet & Spicy Mustart Molasses cookies sandwiched with our lovely Orange Buttercream
  • Whoopie Pies $2.75 ea, $32/dozen
    • Pumpkin Cream Cheese (our best selling whoopie!), Chocolate Chai, Chocolate Cookie Dough, Banana Salted Caramel, Red Velvet
  • Bars $2.50 each, $30/dozen for Classic Bars, $15/dozen for Bite-sized Bars
    • Triple Chocolate Brownies, Caramel Apple Bars, Molly Bars (delicious Blondie-style bars packed with Pretzels, Peanut Butter, & Chocolate)
  • Cookie Dough Truffles (Egg Free!) $9/dozen (Available with a colored drizzle of your choice!  )
    • Chocolate Chip, Pumpkin Chip, Shortbread

Cups & Cakes

All cakes come with writing and basic decorations. Additional designs, sculpted cakes, fondant, and any customization is always available, too!  Give us a call and let us know what you are looking for and we can help you find the perfect fit for your event!

Most of our cakes can be made Gluten Free (often times there is an additional charge) & we do offer a variety of Vegan Cakes–please call and inquire!

  • Seasonal Cakes (6” $30, 8” $39, 9” $45, 10” $59)
    • Pumpkin Yumpkin: Our amazing Pumpkin Cake paired with Cream Cheese Buttercream
    • Caramel Apple: Our Spiced Apple Cake married with our Caramel Buttercream (OR try it with our Cream Cheese Buttercream!)
    • Pistachio with Chocolate & Honey: Our delicious & moist Pistachio Cake layered with Chocolate Ganache & coated with our Honey Buttercream
    • Chocolate & Salted Caramel: Your favorite Chocolate Cake meets it’s perfect partner…Salted Caramel Buttercream
    • Raspberry Cornmeal with Brown Butter: A new favorite at our shop!  Cornmeal Cake paired with our tart & tasty Raspberry jam, covered with Brown Butter Buttercream…we can’t get enough.
      • ASK US ABOUT CUSTOMIZING YOUR CAKES & CUPCAKES–IT’S OUR FAVORITE THING TO DO!
  • Classic Cakes (6ʼʼ $20, 8ʼʼ $30, 9ʼʼ $35, 10ʼʼ $49)
    • Vanilla, Double Chocolate
    • (Our Classic Cakes are paired with our delicious and creamy Vanilla Buttercream, or can be customized with any of our specialty Buttercream flavors; or, try a fresh fruit or jam filling!)
  • Specialty Cakes (6ʼʼ $25, 8ʼʼ $35, 9ʼʼ $39, 10ʼʼ $54)
    • Red Velvet, PIstachio, Cornmeal, Pumpkin, Apple, Lemon, Carrot Cake, Almond, Coconut, Banana Nut
  • Specialty Buttercream Flavors (an additional $5 per cake…and completely worth it): Chocolate, Cream Cheese, Lemon, Almond, Vanilla-Orange, Espresso, Champagne, Pistachio, Peanut Butter, Vernors, Brown Butter, Salted Caramel
  • Filling options (an additional $5 per cake…and completely worth it): Fresh Strawberries, Raspberries, Chocolate Ganache, Peanut Butter Cream, Espresso Cream, Coconut Cream, Pistachio, Rose Buttercream, Champagne Buttercream
  • Signature Cake Combinations (6ʼʼ $30, 8ʼʼ $40, 9ʼʼ $45, 10ʼʼ $60)
    • The King
      • Banana Nut Cake with Peanut Butter Filling and Chocolate Buttercream
    • Creamy, Dreamy Coconut Caramel
      • Our fluffy Vanilla Cake with Coconut Cream filling and Salted Caramel Buttercream
    • Raspberry Red Velvet
      • One of our most popular cakes- Our Red Velvet cake with Raspberry filling and our amazing Cream Cheese Buttercream
    • Almond Joy
      • Our delightful Almond Cake paired with Coconut Cream filling and Chocolate Buttercream
    • Vanilla Raspberry Rose
      • Our lovely Vanilla cake with Raspberry filling and Rose Buttercream
    • Triple Chocolate Pistachio
      • Our decadent Double Chocolate cake filled with Chocolate Ganache and finished off with our irresistible Pistachio Buttercream
  • Cupcakes
    • All cakes can be made into cupcakes, and can be customized for your event!
      Cupcakes start at $2.00 each for classic cupcakes and $2.25 each for specialty cupcakes, with a minimum order of 12. Mini Cupcakes are available starting at $15/dozen.
  • Cake Pops
    • Cake Pops can be made out of any flavor cake! Cake Pops are $1.75 each, $21/dozen. They can be individually packaged and can be custom decorated for your event!
  • Mason Cakes
    • Our Mason Cakes are baked directly inside Mason Jars. They come in all flavors, with fresh buttercream frosting throughout–just open up and literally dig in! Our Mason Cakes make great favors for parties, weddings, and events. They can be custom decorated with special ribbons, fabrics, and can even have custom messaging inside! Mason Cakes start at $4.50 each.

 Pies

Our pies come in various shapes and sizes. Choose your pie flavor, then decide what style pie tickles your fancy!

  • Flavors:
    • Caramel Apple Crumb, Peach Blackberry, Cherry, Triple Berry, Apple Berry, Chess, Chocolate Chess
  • Pie Styles:
    • Classic Pies 9ʼʼ Pies $21.00
    • Pie Jars  $4.50 ea
      • Pies baked in Mason Jars–a great hostess gift, welcome favor, or any time treat!
    • Pie Pops  $21/dz
      • Pie on a stick! Oh my. Everything you love about pie in one or two bites. Available in Caramel Apple Crumb, Triple Berry, Cherry, or Apple Berry.
    • Mini Pies  $2.75 ea, $32/dz
      • Our Mini Pies are baked in cupcake tins and are a unique twist on the classic pie!
    • Hand Pies   $2.75 ea, $32/dz
      • Perfect four-bite turnovers; choose from Caramel Apple Crumb, Triple Berry, Cherry, or Apple Berry.
  • Galettes: New this season, beautiful, free-form pies for two or more!  $4.50 small (feeds 2), $15.00 large (feeds 6ish)
    • Pear Almond Frangipane, Bourbon Apple Cheddar, Fig Walnut Goat Cheese

Candies & Confections

  • Caramels $9/dozen
    • Classic, Chocolate, Fleur de Sel, Lavender
  • Macaron Trifles $4/jar
    • Layers of French Macaron in an adorable Mason Jar!
  • Classic French Macarons $17/dozen
    • We offer a selection of French Macarons in our case each day.  If you would like to order a specific flavor, we ask that you order a minimum of one dozen/flavor.  You are also welcome to order as many as you wish from the flavors featured in our case, or pop in to pick up the quantity you need!  Give us a call to find out what flavors we are featuring!  We offer custom colored shells for an additional $1/dozen.
    • Vanilla Bean, Pistachio, Fig & Goat Cheese, Salted Caramel, Snickerdoodle, Chocolate Chai, Apple Pie, Rosemary Brown Butter, PB&J, Chocolate Espresso, Champagne, Almond, Cookie Dough, Pumpkin Pie, Nutella

Breakfast Bites

  • Cinnamon Rolls, Ready for Baking! $12/four rolls, $18/six rolls
    • A set of our Cinnamon Rolls par-baked and ready for your oven!
  • Scones $2.25ea, $26/dz
    • Cinnamon Sugar, Apple Brown Butter, Pumpkin, Onion & Black Pepper
  • Muffins $26/dozen
    • Morning Glory (Delicious, Vegan, our most popular muffin),  Banana Nut, Pumpkin White Chocolate, Oat & Honey, Apple Streusel
  • Bread Pudding Cups  $1.75 ea, $21/dz
    • Comfort food any time of day!  Our Fall flavors include Cinnamon Pumpkin Chip, Apple Spice, Pear Almond, and our weekly featured pudding!
  • Morning Breads: $1.50/slice, $15/loaf, or $6/mini loaf
    • Banana Streusel, Oatmeal Brown Butter, Apple Cinnamon, Pumpkin
  • Classic French Croissants
    • $2/Classic, $3/Stuffed (Chocolate, Almond, Chocolate Almond), $3.50/savory
  • French Breads…$4.50/loaf
    • Baguettes, Brioche, Asiago Cheese, Focaccia, Sourdough, Multigrain, and more!  The perfect addition to your Thanksgiving meal.

Wedding Cakes

Our Wedding Cakes start at $3.75/serving for buttercream cakes, and $4.75/serving for fondant cakes.  We offer all sorts of custom cakes and creations, and cam provide Cupcake Towers, Dessert Tables, or a sweet simple Cutting Cake for Two.  To serve you best, please call, e-mail, or stop in to schedule a tasting and review our Wedding Cake Menu!  You can also find additional helpful information on our FAQs page.

Custom Sugar Cookies starting at $2.50 each ($2.75 individually packaged with the ribbon color of your choice!)

  • We create custom sugar cookies for weddings, birthdays, holidays, showers, and other events! If you know what youʼre looking for we can find the perfect cookie for your special day.
Special Orders
We do our best to exceed all of your dessert and catering needs.  From breakfast trays to dessert baskets, wedding favors to sweet tables, give us a call to find out how we can create the perfect customized, unique (and stress-free) event for you!